CALDWELL, Idaho — Caldwell Mayor Eric Phillips has selected one finalist to become the city’s next police chief, but the candidate’s identity will remain confidential while additional evaluations are completed.
Caldwell Police Chief Search
The recruitment process closed Oct. 1, 2026, after the city received 17 applications. Caldwell initially narrowed the field to three leading candidates, then identified two strongest finalists following interviews.
Phillips interviewed both finalists individually before choosing one candidate. “After completing the interviews and taking a couple of days to reflect on the candidates, I identified a clear first choice,” Phillips said.
Finalist Must Complete Evaluations
The selected finalist must undergo a comprehensive background investigation, polygraph examination and physical fitness assessment. Independent third-party professionals or organizations will conduct those evaluations.
The candidate must also participate in a final interview with the Caldwell City Council. That interview will take place during a separately scheduled executive session. No date has been set for the session or for formal consideration of the appointment.
The finalist will not appear at the council’s regularly scheduled meeting on Nov. 16, 2026. Phillips will consider feedback from council members before formally submitting the candidate’s name for appointment at a future meeting.
The Caldwell Police Department will remain under interim leadership until the appointment process is complete. Phillips said he wants stability for department employees, confidence among Caldwell residents and strong working relationships with law enforcement partners in Canyon County and the Treasure Valley.